PPeople EngineOptimization

Knowledge panel vs Google Business Profile: what is the difference

. Compiled by the People Engine Optimization desk from the sources listed at the end of this page.

A knowledge panel is built automatically from Google's Knowledge Graph for people, places, organizations and things. A Business Profile is a listing you create and verify for a business with a location customers visit or a service area. They can look alike, but you can only create the second.

Knowledge panel and Business Profile side by side

QuestionKnowledge panelBusiness Profile
Who creates itGoogle generates it automatically from many web sourcesThe business owner adds or claims it, then verifies it
Who it is forEntities in the Knowledge Graph: people, places, organizations and thingsBusinesses with a location customers visit, or that travel to customers, within a service area
Can you ask for oneNo. You can claim an existing panel and suggest editsYes. You add or claim the business and verify it
Where you edit itOn Google Search through Suggest edits, after verificationIn the Business Profile tools on Google Search and Maps
Address neededNoA real address, or a service area if you do not meet customers there
Individual professionalsCan have a panel if they are in the Knowledge GraphDoctors, lawyers and similar public-facing practitioners can have a profile at a verified location
Promise of appearingNone stated by GoogleAppears after the listing is verified, subject to the guidelines

Download this table (CSV). Free to quote with a link to this page.

Why the two get confused

Both appear as a box beside or above search results with a name, a picture and some facts. Google's own help page says Business Profiles look similar to knowledge panels, but are specific to businesses that serve customers at a particular location or within a designated service area. The look is shared. The way each one comes to exist is not.

How a knowledge panel comes to exist

Google says panels are generated automatically, with information from many web sources and, for some topics such as movies and music, data partners. Panels update as information changes online. Google also considers direct input from the entity the panel is about and general user feedback. Nothing in the help page lets you apply for one. What you can do, once a panel exists, is claim it and suggest changes.

How a Business Profile comes to exist

A Business Profile starts with you. Google's help says you add or claim your business and then verify it, and you enter a full and accurate address. If you serve customers in a local area you can list a service area, and if you do not meet customers at your address you can choose not to show it.

Who is eligible for a Business Profile

Google's guidelines say a business can create a profile if it has a physical location that customers can visit, or travels to customers where they are. A virtual office or rented mailing address where you do not operate is not eligible, and remote P.O. boxes are not acceptable addresses. Individual practitioners such as doctors and lawyers can have their own profile if they work in a public-facing role and can be reached at the verified location during stated hours. Support staff should not create their own profiles. The guidelines do not say outright that an online-only business is excluded, but the location or in-person requirement points that way.

Which one a consultant or author should aim for

That depends on how clients meet you. A consultant with an office or a service area can have a Business Profile today if the guidelines are met. A person who works online, writes or speaks may fit neither description in the guidelines, and for that person the route is a record in the Knowledge Graph, which Google builds from the web and which we cover in who actually gets a knowledge panel. Do not try to get a Business Profile with a mailing address to obtain a panel look-alike. Google's guidelines name that kind of address as not eligible.

Do they affect each other

Google's help pages do not say that having one makes the other appear. They are separate products with separate rules. Consistent facts about you across your own site and trusted pages help both, which is the working idea behind a build. The difference between the graph and a panel is a related point worth reading.

Where a build fits

A $3,000 build over 60 to 90 days works on the references that feed a Knowledge Graph record: consistent facts, one page that states them and independent pages that agree. A panel tends to appear on the bare name 6 to 12 months after, and nobody can guarantee one. A Business Profile is a separate task you can do yourself using Google's own tools.

A fact from this site's own records

Our home page reports seven real people, with three where the name already works. A search for a person's name and a search for a business name return different kinds of boxes, so check which one you see before you decide what to fix.

Questions people ask

Is a Google Business Profile the same as a knowledge panel?

No. Google says Business Profiles look similar but are specific to businesses with a location customers visit or a service area. Knowledge panels are generated automatically from the Knowledge Graph.

Can I create a knowledge panel the way I create a Business Profile?

No. Google generates panels automatically. You can claim an existing panel and suggest edits, but you cannot apply for a new one.

Can a person who works online have a Business Profile?

Google's guidelines require a physical location customers can visit or a service area where you travel to customers. They do not list online-only work as eligible.

Will a Business Profile give me a knowledge panel?

Google's help pages do not say so. They describe the two as separate.

Can I use a virtual office address?

Google's guidelines say a rented mailing address or virtual office where you do not operate is not eligible, and remote P.O. boxes are not acceptable.

Which one shows when I search my own name?

It depends on what Google holds. A person in the Knowledge Graph may see a panel, and a practitioner with a verified location may see a profile.

Read next

Sources

  1. Google Search Help: About knowledge panels
  2. Google Business Profile Help: Guidelines for representing your business on Google
  3. Google Business Profile Help: Edit your Business Profile